| back to overview |
Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 41:378-383, (1997)
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
DT = 5 minutes |
DT = 30 minutes |
|
| patients | n = 70 |
n = 70 |
female (%) |
16 |
19 |
age (years) |
59.6 ± 9.5 (43 - 70) |
61.2 ± 8.8 (44 - 76) |
mean height (cm) |
172.2 ± 8.5 (155 - 186) |
169.9 ± 8.1 (155 - 182) |
mean weight (kg) |
82.1 ± 13.9 (57 - 113) |
81.4 ± 12.2 (53 - 105) |
LV-EFa (%) |
64.8 ± 11.6 |
65.3 ± 12.5 |
| risk factors | ||
smoking |
40 % |
35 % |
hypertension |
47 % |
49 % |
high cholesterol |
52 % |
59 % |
diabetes |
19 % |
22 % |
| number of punctures | ||
arterial punctures |
1.0 ± 0.0 |
1.0 ± 0.0 |
venous punctures |
0.2 ± 0.6 |
0.3 ± 0.5 |
connective tissue punctures |
0.7 ± 0.7 |
0.6 ± 0.7 |
| At sheath removal | ||
systolic BP (mmHg) |
134.5 ± 18.6 |
138.5 ±19.3 |
diastolic BP (mmHg) |
82.8 ± 8.3 |
79.7 ± 11.2 |
ACT (s)b |
227 ± 52 (166 - 321) |
223 ± 37 (174 - 303) |
There was no statistical difference in demographic characteristics as well as in blood pressure or ACT at time of sheath removal between those patients randomized to a deployment time (DT) of 5 min or a DT of 30 min. The number of inadvertent venous or connective tissue punctures was identical; patients with more than one arterial puncture were excluded. (aLV-EF, left ventricular ejection fraction, bACT, activated coagulation time)
Table II: Bleeding classification immediately after the deployment of HPCD, hematoma size before ambulation, and patients' own characterization of the local symptoms the next morning.
DT = 5 minutes |
DT = 30 minutes |
|
| bleeding after deployment | ||
no bleeding |
74 % |
71 % |
little oozing |
26 % |
29 % |
brisk ooze |
0 % |
0% |
severe pulsatile bleeding |
0 % |
0 % |
| Ecchymosis size after 24 hours (cm2) | 6.2 ± 4.4 |
6.8 ± 8.2 |
| patients' own characterization | ||
comfortable |
41% |
57 % |
slightly uncomfortable |
52% |
43 % |
uncomfortable |
7 % |
0 % |
very uncomfortable |
0 % |
0 % |
There was no statistical difference between those patients randomized to a deployment time (DT) of 5 min or a DT of 30 min
Biodegradable collagen induces platelet activation and aggregation,
releasing coagulation factors and resulting in the formation of
fibrin and the subsequent generation of a thrombus [29]. Collagen
is ultimately degraded and resorbed by granulocytes and macrophages.
Antigenicity of purified collagen is considerably reduced and,
although allergies to collagen are described [30], allergic reactions
to collagen used for hemostasis have not been a clinical problem
[1, 2, 9]. Today, besides the suture-mediated closure of arterial
puncture sites [16], two different collagen devices are predominantly
available: the VHD (Vascular Hemostatic Device, VasoSeal®,
Datascope Corp., Montvale, NJ, USA) and the HPCD .
Hemostasis with collagen devices immediately after PTCA
VHD was investigated in several randomized studies where sheaths
were pulled immediately after PTCA, showing a highly significant
reduction in time to hemostasis as compared to manual compression
(with delayed sheath removal, of course): Time to hemostasis for
VHD ranged between 5 and 7 minutes [9, 31, 32]. These measurements
for time to hemostasis were in good agreement with earlier VHD-studies,
which were either non-randomized or reported only the total results
for diagnostic and interventional procedures [1 - 5]. Although
it is assumed that the hemostasis induced by VHD is independent
of the level of anticoagulation [1, 33], it seems that time to
hemostasis of 5 to 7 minutes is longer in patients on full anticoagulation
than in patients after PTCA with delayed sheath removal (7.6 ±
11.6 min on heparin, 4.3 ± 3.7 min off heparin [9] or five
hours after PTCA with 3 ± 3 minutes [34]). In the setting
of aggressive anticoagulation, bleeding complications are particularly
likely to occur [35]. Therefore, the hypothesis of collagen-induced
hemostasis being independent of the presence or the level of anticoagulation
may be questioned.
For HPCD, the data are sparse regarding hemostasis when sheaths
are pulled immediately after PTCA: De Swart et al. reported 16
patients with immediate sheath pulling after PTCA [8]; time to
hemostasis, however, was mixed with patients undergoing diagnostic
catheterization. In the US multicenter trial, sheaths were pulled
after approximately 8 hours (465 ± 523 min) in the 46 patients
assigned to HPCD at an ACT of 213 ± 89 s [11]. HPCD proved
to be safe and effective with a significant reduction in time
to hemostasis from 19.6 ± 12.6 to 3.5 ± 8.5 [11].
These data were consistent with earlier findings from non-randomized
or general reports on patients after diagnostic and interventional
procedures [8, 36, 37].
In our opinion, it is difficult to compare the results for time to hemostasis reported for VHD and for HPCD, because different methods for measurement were used: for VHD, time to hemostasis is defined as the time elapsed from initial compression at removal of the sheath until the completion of compression. The time interval between each check is not standardized and is reported to be in the range between 1 [9] and 5 [2] minutes. These choices, however, have a considerable impact on the results: too short intervals may not be sufficient to give enough time for thrombus formation and increase--particularly in the manual control groups--the time to hemostasis. For HPCD, the method suggested to determine time to hemostasis is different: inherent to the anchor concept ("sandwich technique"), hemostasis is usually immediate and no compression is required. In the US multicenter trial, no initial compression was applied to the puncture site and time to hemostasis was measured as the time from device deployment to an absence of bleeding. In our study, we therefore decided not to determine the time to hemostasis but to more carefully describe the --albeit little-- bleedings.
As our results show, sheaths can be safely pulled immediately
after PTCA with the HPCD device. Immediate hemostasis was obtained
in 102 of the 140 enrolled patients (73%). Our results are in
good agreement with the immediate hemostasis rate of 76% reported
by the US multicenter trial in the 46 PTCA patients [11]. HPCD
obviously offers several advantages: it is deployed through an
arterial sheath, not requiring an additional tissue dilation.
No occlusive pressure must be applied above the deployment site.
The entire device is absorbable and it appears to leave no sequelae
after 30 - 60 days [8, 37].
Limitations of this study
In this study, a rigorous patient selection was applied and
the results cannot be extrapolated to patients excluded. Furthermore,
our study was not primarily designed to evaluate the important
issue of cost reduction by hemostasic devices due to early ambulation
and decreased length of hospital stay [39-41]. The decision when
to ambulate and discharge patients was left to the physicians
on the wards. Therefore, it is not surprising that the patients
were not walked at night but rather after approximately 24 hours.
To our knowledge, no study using a hemostatic device in PTCA patients
defined early ambulation as an endpoint [3, 38, 41].
CONCLUSIONS
The use of a collagen system with an intraarterial anchor (HPCD) is effective and safe when sheaths are pulled immediately after PTCA. The reduction of deployment time from 30 minutes to 5 minutes is not related to an increased risk of bleeding or other vascular complications. This makes handling of the HPCD easier, because the suture may be cut while the patients are still on the table in the cath lab. Furthermore, patients can be transferred much faster to the intermediate care unit, thereby reducing the burden on the personnel in the cath lab. The transfer of PTCA patients to the floor already without a sheath is welcomed by the staff of the intermediate care units. Obviously, if patients are hemodynamically unstable and require arterial pressure monitoring, it may not be appropriate to use a hemostatic device to remove the sheath early. Cost/effectiveness analysis has yet to prove savings which may be generated by decreased duration of hospital stay by discharge within 24 hours [42] or even the same day on an outpatient basis in carefully selected PTCA patients [43].
References
1, Ernst SMPG, Tjonjoegin RM, Schräder R, Kaltenbach M, Sigwart U, Sanborn TA, Plokker HWT: Immediate Sealing of Arterial Puncture Sites After Cardiac Catheterization and Coronary Angioplasty Using a Biodegradable Collagen Plug: Results of an International Registry. J Am Coll Cardiol 21:851-855, 1993.
2, Schräder R, Steinbacher S, Burger W, Kadel C, Vallbracht C, Kaltenbach M: Collagen Application for Sealing of Arterial Puncture Sites in Comparison to Pressure Dressing: A Randomized Trial. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 27:298-302, 1992.
3, Foran JPM, Patel D, Brookes J, Wainwright JR: Early mobilisation after percutaneous cardiac catheterisation using collagen plug (VasoSeal) haemostasis. Br Heart J 69:424-429, 1993.
4, Bartorelli AL, Sganzerla P, Fabbiocchi F, Montorsi P, De Cesare N, Child M, Tavasci E, Passaretti B, Loaldi A: Prompt and safe femoral hemostasis with a collagen device after intracoronary implantation of Palmaz-Schatz stents. Am Heart J 130:26-32, 1995.
5, Gibbs JSR, Slade AKB, Blake J, Nordrehaug JE, Rickards AF, Buller NP, Sigwart U: Femoral Arterial Hemostasis Using a Collagen Plug After Coronary Artery Stent Implantation. J Interven Cardiol 5:85-88,1992.
6, Camenzind E, Grossholz M, Urban P, Dorsaz PA, Didier D, Meier B: Collagen application versus manual compression: a prospective randomized trial for arterial puncture site closure after coronary angioplasty. J Am Coll Cardiol 24:655-662,1994.
7, Silber S, Dörr R, Rösch A, Mühling H: Complications After Collagen Plugging for Hemostasis Following Femoral Puncture: Experience in Over 3000 Patients. Circulation 92:I-56, 1995.
8, de Swart H, Dijkman L, Hofstra L, Bär FW, Van Ommen V, Tordoir J, Wellens HJJ: A New Hemostatic Puncture Closure Device for the Immediate Sealing of Arterial Puncture Sites. Am J Cardiol 72:445-449, 1993.
9, Sanborn TA, Gibbs HH, Brinker JA, Knopf WA, Kosinski EJ, Roubin GS: A Multicenter Randomized Trial Comparing a Percutaneous Collagen Hemostasis Device With Conventional Manual Compression After Diagnostic Angiography and Angioplasty. J Am Coll Cardiol 22:1273-1279, 1993.
10, Hinohara T, Vetter JW, Ribeiro E, Webb J, Carere R, Cohen E, Simpson JB: New Percutaneous Procedure to Achieve Immediate Hemostasis Following Sheath Removal. Circulation 92:I-410, 1995.
11, Kussmaul WG 3rd, Buchbinder M, Whitlow PL, Aker UT, Heuser RR, King SB, Kent KM, Leon MB, Kolansky DM, Sandza JG Jr: Rapid arterial hemostasis and decreased access site complications after cardiac catheterization and angioplasty: results of a randomized trial of a novel hemostatic device. J Am Coll Cardiol 25:1685-1692, 1995.
12, Bogart DB, Bogart MA, Miller JT, Farrar MW, Barr WK, Montgomery MA: Femoral artery catheterization complications: a study of 503 consecutive patients. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 34:8-13,1995.
13, Krone RJ, Johnson L, Noto T and the Registry Committee of the Society for Cardiac Angiography and Interventions. Five Year Trends in Cardiac Catheterization: A Report from the Registry of the Society for Cardiac Angiography and Interventions. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 39:31-35,1996.
14, Waksman R, Scott NA, Ghazzal ZMB, Mays R, Frerichs FA, Petersen JY, King III SB: Randomized comparison of flexible versus nonflexible femoral sheaths on patient comfort after angioplasty. Am Heart J 131:1076-1078, 1996.
15, Christensen B, Lacarella C, Manion R, Bruhn-Ding B, Meyer S, Wilson R: Sandbags Do Not Prevent Complications After Catheterization. Circulation 90:I-205,1994.
16, Carere RG, Webb JG, Ahmed T, Dodek AA:,Initial Experience Using Prostar: A New Device for Percutaneous Suture-Mediated Closure of Arterial Puncture Sites. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 37: 367-372,1996.
17, Scriver V, Crowe J, Wilkinson A, Meadowcroft C: A randomized controlled trial of the effectiveness of exercise and/or alternating air mattress in the control of back pain after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty. Heart Lung 23: 308-316,1994.
18, Resar JR, Prewitt KC, Wolff MR, Blumenthal R, Raqueno JV, Brinker JA: Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty through 6F diagnostic catheters: a feasibility study. Am Heart J 125:1591-1596, 1993.
19, Villavicencio R,Urban P, Muller T, Favre J, Meier B: Coronary balloon angioplasty through diagnostic 6 French catheters. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 22:56-59,1991.
20, Panayiotou H, Norris JW, Forman MB: Coronary angioplasty at the time of initial catheterization using small diagnostic catheters. Am Heart J 119:204-205,1990.
21, Feldman R, Glemser E, Kaizer J, Stadley M: Coronary angioplasty using new 6 French guiding catheters. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 23:93-99, 1991.
22, Salinger MH, Kern MJ: First use of 5 French diagnostic catheter as a guiding catheter for percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 18:276-278,1989.
23 Moles VP, Meier B, Urban P, de la Serna F, Pande AK: Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty through 4 French diagnostic catheters. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 25:98-100,1992.
24, Cragg AH, Nakagawa N, Smith TP, Berbaum KS: Hematoma formation after diagnostic angiography: effect of catheter size. J Vasc Interv Radiol 2:231- 233,1991.
25, Waksman R, King III SB, Douglas JS, Shen Y, Ewing H, Mueller L, Ghazzal ZMB, Weintraub WS: Predictors of Groin Complications After Balloon and New-Device Coronary Intervention. Am J Cardiol 75:886-889,1995.
26, Campeu IG: Percutaneous transradial artery approach for coronary angiography. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 16:3-7,1989.
27, Kiemeneij F, Laarman G: Percutaneous transradial artery approach for the coronary stent implantation. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 30:173-178,1993.
28, Lotan C, Hasin Y, Mosseri M, Rozenman Y, Admon D, Nassar H, Gotsman MS: Transradial approach for coronary angiography and angioplasty. Am J Cardiol 76:164-167, 1995.
29, Chvapil M, Holubec H: Effect of Hemostatic Fleece on 14C-Serotonin Release by Human Platelets. Jpn Pharmacol Ther 18:57(2913)-62(2918), 1990.
30, Kitamura K, Yasuoka R, Ohara M, Shimotsuma M, Hagiwara A, Yamane T, Yamaguchi T, Takahashi T: How safe are the xenogeneic hemostats?--Report of a case of severe systemic allergic reaction. Surg Today 25:433-435,1995.
31, v.Hoch F, Neumann F-J,Theiss W, Kastrati A, Schömig A: Efficacy and safety of collagen implants for haemostasis of the vascular access site after coronary balloon angioplasty and coronary stent implantation. Europ Heart J 16:640-646,1995.
32, Slaughter PM, Chetty R, Flintoft VF, Lewis S, Sykora K, Beattie DM, Schwartz L: A single center randomized trial assessing use of a vascular hemostasis device vs. conventional manual compression following PTCA: what are the potential resource savings? Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 34:210-214, 1995.
33, Chvapil M, Chvapil TA: Hemostatic Effectiveness of Hemostatic Collagen Fleece (Novacol) in Heparinized and Aspirin Treated Rabbits. Jpn Pharmacol Ther 18:43(2899)-48(2904),1990.
34, Silber S, Björvik A, Rösch A, Mühling H: Advantages of Sealing Arterial Puncture Sites After PTCA with a Single Collagen Plug: A Randomized, Prospective Trial. J Am Coll Cardiol 23:262A,1995.
35, Carere R., Webb J, Dodek A:Collagen Plug Closure of Femoral Arterial Punctures. Are Complications Excessive? Circulation 90:I-621,1994.
36, Chevalier B, Lancelin B, Berthaux X: Hemostatic Puncture Closure Device Versus Regular Compression: A Randomized Study. J Am Coll Cardiol 23:93A,1995.
37, Aker UT, Kensey KR, Heuser RR, Sandza JG, Kussmaul WG 3rd: Immediate arterial hemostasis after cardiac catheterization: initial experience with a new puncture closure device. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 31:228-232,1994.
38, Silber S, Zindler G, Dörr R, Mühling H, Luckas Ch: Intra-Arterial Anchoring is Superior to Plain Collagen Plugging for Sealing Arterial Puncture Sites and Ambulating After 20 Minutes. Circulation 92:I-225,1995.
39, Krause PB, Klein LW: Utility of a Percutaneous Collagen Hemostasis Device: To Plug or Not to Plug? J Am Coll Cardiol 22:1280-1282,1993.
40, Satler LF, Mintz G: Percutaneous Hemostatic Closure Systems: Is the cost worth the price? Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 37:373-374,1996.
41, Vainer J, Meier B: Has the Time Come for the Plug? Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 37:366,1996.
42, Cragg DR, Friedman HZ, Almany SL, Gangadharan V, Ramos RG, Levine AB, LeBeau TA, O'Neill WW: Early Hospital Discharge After Percutaneous Transluminal Coronary Angioplasty. Am J Cardiol 64:1270-1274,1989.
43, Staphorst S, Springorum B, Bollen N, Kiemeneij F: Transradial coronary stenting in outpatients. Europ Heart J 16:169,1995.
- Correspondence to:
- Sigmund Silber, MD, FACC
- Professor of Medicine
- Dr. Müller Hospital
- Am Isarkanal 36
- D-81379 München
- Tel: (+ 49 89) 74 21 51-0
- Fax (+ 49 89) 74 21 51 99
- e-mail: ssilber@med.de